Milwaukee’s snap-off blade utility knives and new heavy duty scissors all have iron carbide cutting edges. My first instinct was to dismiss this as marketing fluff. Iron carbide sounds cool and fancy, but most users won’t know what to make of this. They might be impressed without even knowing what this means.
When you hear carbide, it’s mostly in regard to tungsten carbide cutting tools. Iron Carbide is, as you might have guessed, an alloy that consists of iron and carbon. You’ve heard of low- and high-carbon steel, right? Iron carbide typically has a much greater weight percentage of carbon than high-carbon steel.
Advertisement
I reached out to Milwaukee, asking if they had some high-magnification images to show the differences between iron carbide and regular steel or stainless steel cutting blades.
In the comparison image above, an iron carbide blade (left) and stainless steel blade (right) were used to cut through a tough and abusive material, such as a metal pallet banding strap. As you can see, the cutting edge on the iron carbide blade is a little worn, but still sharp. The edge of the stainless steel blade is heavily worn and dulled down.
When Milwaukee engineers designed their new scissors, they kept in mind that most pros were using scissors with stainless steel blades, and that stainless steel blades quickly dull when used to cut tough materials. No, jobsite scissors aren’t often meant for cutting things like metal pallet straps, but they’re used in such a manner anyway.
Milwaukee’s iron carbide-edged blades have harder cutting edges than stainless steel blades. This means that edge retention will be a lot longer, and that the scissors won’t dull as quickly or easily.
The added brittleness of iron carbide is likely why the new scissors only have an iron carbide edge. This way, you have added hardness and edge durability where you need it most, and added toughness and reduced brittleness where you don’t.
Since iron carbide is a very hard material, it’s also going to be more brittle, compared to stainless steel. I’ve been using a Milwaukee iron carbide-edged snap-off utility knife, but haven’t noticed any unusual chipping of the blades. I did notice that the blades do last longer than other brands’ blades.
Advertisement
To sum it up, an iron carbide cutting edge means such tools will stay sharper for longer. Yes, iron carbide is an attention-grabbing keyword, but it’s one that translates to real-world benefits.
fred
Thanks for the informative tutorial.
In the shop we had dedicated strap cutters (rather than scissors or tin snips) on the loading dock . I don’t recall that they ever were sharpened – but seemed to work consistently. I believe that ours were HK Porter brand – and fairly long 2-handed affairs – but I found this shorter one on Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Porter-1290G-Steel-Strap-Cutter/dp/B0002FT5XG
cb
Do you know the HRC/Rockwell hardness value # of these scissors?
Stuart
No, sorry. Even if I had a tester on hand, the iron carbide cutting edge is too narrow and thin to easily test.
JG
Good stuff but I sharpen all my stainless stell, not sure how would that iron carbide go.
John
How comes when ever I see anything about high end cutting knives they all say SS is the worst possible choice for a quality blade because its to soft and does not hold an edge. Perhaps this test would have been better done next to a tungsten carbide blade. May as well use a chocolate blade over SS lol
Stuart
Stainless steel isn’t all that bad, and heat treatment can make a difference as well.
When you read about high end knives, any blade that’s not made from super-premium sintered powdered alloys, such as Elmax, is going to be inferior.
Mike
Depends on the stainless alloy used. Carbide can be sharpened with diamond stones or wheels.
Håvard
8 years later I found this post because Milwaukee recently refreshed these scissors (the Jobsite series, 48-22-4041 and 48-22-4040) with a new series that doesn’t seem to have iron carbide edges anymore (48-22-4046 and 48-22-4047). Do you have any contacts in Milwaukee who could tell you why they moved away from that?
Stuart
I will do my best to find out!