ToolGuyd

Tool Reviews, New Tool Previews, Best Tool Guides, Tool Deals, and More!

  • New Tools
  • Reviews
  • Guides
    • Best Cordless Power Tool Brand
    • Tool Brands: Who Owns What?
    • Best Cordless Drills (2021)
    • Dewalt UWO Explained
    • Where to Buy Tools
    • Best Tool Kit Upgrades
    • Best Extension Cord Size
    • Best Tape Measure
    • Best Safety Gear
    • Best Precision Screwdrivers
    • Best Tool Brands in Every Category
    • Ultimate Tool Gift Guide
    • More Buying Guides
  • Hand Tools
    • Bit Holders & Drivers
    • EDC, Pocket, & Multitools
    • Electrical Tools
    • Flashlights & Worklights
    • Knives
    • Mechanics’ Tools
    • Pliers
    • Screwdrivers
    • Sockets & Drive Tools
    • Wrenches
    • All Hand Tools
  • Power Tools
    • Accessories
    • Cordless
    • Drills & Drivers
    • Oscillating Tools
    • Saws
    • Woodworking Tools
    • All Power Tools
  • Brands
    • Bosch
    • Craftsman
    • Dewalt
    • Makita
    • Milwaukee
    • Ryobi
    • All Brands
  • USA-Made
  • Deals
ToolGuyd > Power Tools > Power Tool Accessories > You Run Out of Screwdriver Bits and Head to Home Depot – Do You Buy Dewalt, Makita, or Milwaukee?

You Run Out of Screwdriver Bits and Head to Home Depot – Do You Buy Dewalt, Makita, or Milwaukee?

Oct 3, 2019 Stuart 122 Comments

If you buy something through our links, ToolGuyd might earn an affiliate commission.

Milwaukee Makita Dewalt Screwdriver Bits at Home Depot

Oops, you ran out of screwdriver bits. You head out to Home Depot and find a selection of Dewalt MaxFit, Makita Gold, and Milwaukee Shockwave screwdriver bits and fastening accessories. Which brand do you buy?

Of these three brands, I’d look at Milwaukee Shockwave first. Milwaukee has become my go-to brand for general purpose drill bits, hole saws, screwdriver bits, and nutdrivers.

Advertisement

I buy Dewalt MaxFit bits if I need a size or style that I can’t find on the Milwaukee side of the pegboard, or if I only need two bits instead of five.

Makita bits are great too, but Home Depot’s selection is always extremely limited.

So which would you buy? Dewalt? Makita? Milwaukee? Something else? Do you skip HD and visit a different supplier?

Related posts:

Milwaukee Shockwave Matrix Carbide Screwdriver Insert BitMilwaukee Matrix Carbide Impact Bits – from Beginning to End

Sections: Power Tool Accessories Tags: impact screwdriver bits, screwdriver bitsMore from: Dewalt, Makita, Milwaukee

« What do You See in this Crescent Lufkin Shockforce Tape Measure Promo Image?
New Bosch Turbo and Diablo Step Drill Bits are Swiss-Made, Impact-Rated »

122 Comments

  1. Mosh

    Oct 3, 2019

    Probably going to buy DeWalt, for driving.
    Not the best experience with some of the other.

    Reply
    • Kim Alan Flaig

      Oct 3, 2019

      What is WRONG Lennox specializes in blades of ALL kinds
      You might pay a little more but I think they last Maybe twice as long as others mentioned

      Reply
      • Lauren

        Oct 4, 2019

        I’m not going to HD, I will go my my local tool guy and grab the bits I need. He order multipacks of 4 inch Irwin #3 Phillips impact bits for me that everyone else just doesn’t have and isn’t willing to order.

        Reply
        • Thomas Jones Jr

          Mar 22, 2021

          Agreed Lauren,
          IRWIN has been on point with quality & performance … They need a marketing team … … … like Milwaukee’s …

          Reply
    • OldDominionDIYer

      Oct 3, 2019

      I have been using Milwaukee but I’m having some issues with them so I might try one of the other brands. I used Dewalt first but honestly think they are about the same as Milwaukee so I may go with another brand next.

      Reply
    • Joe

      Oct 3, 2019

      The best screwdriver bits are made by Bosch. They bought Vermont America years ago and acquired the groved Phillip’s head, which holds much better than any other brand. Remember the Vermont America Claw screwdrivers? The bits have the same design. They are the best. Nothing better.

      Reply
      • David

        Oct 4, 2019

        I bought by chance Vermont America bits and have been impressed by the performance.

        Reply
      • ManOMagik

        Oct 5, 2019

        Actually Boschs’ tool division is mainly made in Malaysia, Mexico, Taiwan and China with only a few from Germany and Switzerland. Personally, I go with Chapman for bits, Diablo for all my blades and channellock for all my wrench and cutter needs. All US companies.

        Reply
        • Stuart

          Oct 5, 2019

          Diablo is owned by Bosch…

          Reply
          • Brad

            Oct 5, 2019

            And Diablo blades are made in Italy

          • LG

            Oct 9, 2019

            Ah I see Bosch acquired Freud & all of its subsidiaries! I was about to say… I love Freud miter saw blades! When boss has them sharpened i throw a Freud blade on my flex slider! He doesn’t actually know the different between Freud to avanti, old school dude, if they cut good they are good lol I’m partial to the finer things especially when Builders are buying aye?!

      • Christopher Trafnik

        Apr 25, 2020

        I concur

        Reply
    • B. Green

      Oct 4, 2019

      Milwaulkee for drill bits, DeWalt max fit for driver bits.

      Reply
      • Mike Boney

        Oct 8, 2019

        Freud manufacturers all of Diablos sawblades. I’d spring for a freud though, there more industrial grade.

        Reply
  2. Addison

    Oct 3, 2019

    Makita.

    Reply
    • Nathaniel M

      Oct 3, 2019

      Second,

      Have had great luck with the couple sets I have.

      The new Milwaukee ECX bits are a must have too.

      Reply
      • Gene

        Oct 4, 2019

        I’ve had problems with dewalt breaking, Milwaukee all the way!

        Reply
      • Shane

        Oct 4, 2019

        Makita is where it’s at. I have all 3 brands. And honestly it’s. Makita number one. Milwaukee second and Dewalt third. All decent bits. But I also have Bosch and they’re last for sure

        Reply
        • Shane

          Oct 4, 2019

          Btw I work with these bits daily. I work for a good sized construction company in Marietta Ohio called Moran construction.

          Reply
  3. Dennis

    Oct 3, 2019

    I go Milwaukee, Dewalt, Makita too. Although I don’t remember the last time I ran out, because I find myself buying a bunch of bit sets during November and December at Home Depot. It’s hard to resist the seasonal combo pack sales they have every year.

    Reply
    • Kyle W Mort

      Oct 4, 2019

      Milwaukee shockwave are junk. DeWalt is overpriced. Give me something thats cheap and lasts long. Any advice?

      Reply
      • Dennis

        Oct 4, 2019

        Try Wiha

        Reply
        • Damon Brown

          May 31, 2020

          Wiha and Wera are by far the most recommended in the knife collectors circles. They don’t round out due to poor fit and soft metal

          Reply
  4. Chris

    Oct 3, 2019

    All my tools are DeWalt so I have to buy DeWalt bits.

    Reply
    • Vlad

      Oct 3, 2019

      Stay strong, we understand your pain )

      Reply
    • Chris

      Oct 3, 2019

      I work for a large fabrication company and we have tried all types of bits, DeWalt, Ryobi ,Irwin even Hilti nothing lasts as long as the Milwaukee shockwave especially when driving screws into metal. We have a large selection of different bits and gradually as we use our stock we changed to the Milwaukee shockwave, buying them online in bulk can’t beat the price either.

      Reply
    • Kurt

      Oct 4, 2019

      Milwaukee seems to be cutting corners! Might just be the holiday deals, but I am seeing defect after defect! Sticking with DeWalt due to a long history of quality over time.

      Reply
      • John

        Oct 4, 2019

        Defect after defect? What do you mean. I’m using Milwaukee shockwave and like their newer bits. I can’t stand DeWalt bits i don’t know why but just despise then

        Reply
        • Chris

          Oct 4, 2019

          Can’t say I’ve ever despised anything in my life without any reason whatsoever.

          Reply
          • Thomas Jones Jr

            Mar 22, 2021

            Right … If I despise something , I can damn sure tell you why …

  5. Szymon

    Oct 3, 2019

    I would go with Milwaukee
    Than maybe makita

    Have not had good success with Dewalt.

    Reply
    • Chris

      Oct 3, 2019

      Such a unique comment compared to ‘Mosh’ above. Just goes to show they’re likely all the same with different packaging.

      Reply
      • Mosh

        Oct 3, 2019

        Actually sorry.
        DeWalt first gen impact no good.
        I try not to use impact rated never exploded on me and doesn’t wear out as fast

        Reply
  6. Ryan

    Oct 3, 2019

    Makita. I have only broken a few tips in my life, and they were all Milwaukee Shockwave. Makita and Irwin both last much longer and do not break. Everything else I own is Milwaukee including the impact gun to drive the screws, but no longer with Shockwave bits.

    Reply
    • ChrisP

      Oct 5, 2019

      I have had a lot of Irwin PH2 failures. A 3/8 impact hex adaptor broke on first use and my 6″ impact extension has so much run out I only ever used it twice. Gave up on the brand.

      Noticed that since the SBD takeover everything is new. Probably a different OEM.

      Reply
      • ChrisP

        Oct 5, 2019

        My issues were with the old Irwin (newel rubbermaid). I will probably try the new Irwin

        Reply
  7. Philip Proctor

    Oct 3, 2019

    Whichever ones are on sale.

    Reply
    • Kenneth Stephens

      Oct 3, 2019

      I’m with this guy

      Reply
    • MikeIt

      Oct 3, 2019

      I too am with this guy. I am just a home gamer though. However, after asking us what we saw in the Lufkin promo image I think this is another test for us. The first thing I saw was the “LASTS 10X LONGER” and “UP TO 50X LIFE” but compared to what? When ever I see “marketing” I tend to start questioning the claims that follow. I would also question why I need to buy new bits. If its because I tend to lose them or they walk off then maybe I wouldn’t spend top dollar on them. If all my bits are worn down to a nub then maybe I would look at a more durable bit. Then taking those factors in to account, I would buy the cheapest that meet my requirement. Also, I would be buying a SQUARE drive bit. I am a recent square drive convert and made sure all my project screws are square drive compatible.

      Reply
  8. Charles A Andrews

    Oct 3, 2019

    I like the Bosch bits and boxes.

    Reply
    • SP

      Oct 4, 2019

      I’ll have what he is having… …

      Where i live (mid east) Milwaukee tools, powertools and accessories are expensive. Very expensive. I would say that Bosch, Makita and Metabo HPT / Hikoki are the most popular among pros and DIYers.

      Reply
  9. Robear

    Oct 3, 2019

    1. Hercules 2. Norske 3. Milwaukee 4. Any brand that isn’t Dewalt. I just don’t like yellow and having the same tools as every other person at the job site.

    Reply
  10. Adam

    Oct 3, 2019

    I never loved the original Shockwave (silver accents), and found myself preferring Irwin. Then tried some Dewalt which were good, but fell back Milwaukee when they upgraded the line (red accents) & have been content since, but if something significantly better came out I’d probably prefer that (like I only buy carbide sawzall blades now).

    I just ran into the Spax rep in HD the other day (which I don’t think I’ve ever seen before). What caught my eye was he had a Wera bit driver on his table, which I asked “why he had such a nice driver that I can’t even buy here.” He said they once had a promo kit that had different bits & drivers, and were Wera sourced.
    He went on to say that some of the bits included in the boxes are Wera, but also sourced from several other companies. I always thought they included junk, but sounded like Spax does have some standards.

    Reply
    • Anton

      Oct 4, 2019

      That’s surprising, I like the screws and small cases that they come in, but hate there screw head design, never had good luck with them. I think I found that a #1 Phillips bit works better than the included for there smaller #6-8 dia from 1” and down. But I still buy because I think they are the best you can get from homer Depot.

      Reply
    • Joe

      Oct 4, 2019

      All I own is dewalt, I’ve tried other brands with the same results. Do I’ll stick with dewalt.

      Reply
  11. Joatman

    Oct 3, 2019

    I’m not sure how I acquired so many bits over the years, but I think I’m set for life. And yes, I use the heck out of them……mostly Dewalt, Bosch and Mikita. Some cheaper brands, as well. As long as I use the correct size, I honestly don’t think I’d ever be able to tell the difference between the brands…..but I do want to try Milwaukee. If all of my bits magically turned into teeth, I’d probably have enough to take care of the entire NHL.

    Reply
  12. Aaron

    Oct 3, 2019

    Every one of my cordless tools, and half my corded, are Milwaukee. However, I prefer DeWalt bits for diving. I find that the Milwaukee will slowly wear out, while the DeWalt just eventually shear off completely. While the Milwaukee may last longer, their end-of-life use tends to deform or strip fasteners too much. Though, I’m probably just going to get whichever is on sale…

    Reply
  13. The What?

    Oct 3, 2019

    In the 20 years I’ve been doing construction and remodeling I don’t recall ever running out of bits. In fact I’ve accumulated enough bits to fill almost 2 cigar boxes. So I won’t be needing bits any time soon. And considering that most screws sold at HD come with a bit, like the ones that I typically use, there’s really no reason to spend the money on extra bits you’ll likely never need. Plus none of the brands that are mentioned make a bit for the screws I use. And typically the bit that comes with the fasteners are always better than the aftermarket brands such as Dewalt, Milwaukee, etc. The last bits I bought were some makita bits but it was only cuz they were gold and I could see it if I dropped it. That was a few years ago and now that’s the only brand I’ll buy and carry with me on the job. I guess Milwaukee & Dewalt think that bs marketing wank is more important than visibility. They sure as hell ain’t doing anyone a favor by making their bits black and gray. So I could see running out of their bits from being dropped & never found.

    Reply
  14. Aaron

    Oct 3, 2019

    *driving… My one key doesn’t stay connected to my phone when it’s under water.

    Reply
  15. Stacey

    Oct 3, 2019

    If the price is similar, I’d pick Milwaukee, otherwise the cheapest.

    Reply
    • Mike

      Oct 3, 2019

      I refurbish the bits tip by filling the point a little flat so it grips without slipping or stripping the screw head( apex tips only .I buy quality tips on sale.

      Reply
  16. Roger

    Oct 3, 2019

    DeWalt Maxfit. But only on specials. Other than that I get FlexTorq from Lowes. Lasts longer. Keep away from Ryobi, Warrior, and Hercules. Milwaukee driver bits have a bad reputation. Gen1 used to twist, and the Gen3 recently just got canceled after it’s debut. Vermont American (SBD) used to make some really nice bits. I still have the one piece extension. Impacts like no other.

    Reply
  17. Frank D

    Oct 3, 2019

    I have bits for life …

    Value will be a consideration.
    Same price for a 5 pack for all three brands?

    Dewalt I’d skip.
    Ideally Makita.
    Otherwise fall back on Milwaukee.

    Reply
  18. Shyerwood

    Oct 3, 2019

    I have used them all and prefer the Bosch. But if I had to choose, it would be Milwaukee.

    Reply
  19. pr20de

    Oct 3, 2019

    While I have 4 Milwaukee M12 tools, I’m largely a DeWalt guy. However, most my bits are Milwaukee. No real reason, they just look better.

    Reply
  20. S

    Oct 3, 2019

    Makita Gold. They are fantastic.

    I won’t buy any Milwaukee bits, any more. I’ve had more failures with them, than any other. I’ve not had a good record with DeWalt bits, either. Have had them chip.

    Reply
    • Brian

      Oct 5, 2019

      I second this!

      Makita Golds by a far shot. I have used many variations of each brand and neither Milwaukee or Dewalt come close in holding power or longevity . I’m not a fan of Makitas other tools, but their bits are the only ones I buy now.

      Reply
  21. David J.

    Oct 3, 2019

    I found that Home Depot can vary on bit selection. I went to a Home Depot on the west coast (Washington state)and they had a really good selection of bits, a lot better than on the east coast (Florida) ironic since the store was smaller and selection too.

    Reply
  22. Corey Moore

    Oct 3, 2019

    I’ve snapped more Milwaukee than anything, I’ve smooshed more DeWalt, and I’ve never really had issues with Makita longevity, but they don’t seem to agree with one handed impact chucks for me. That being, I’ve got a backlog of all three that I never intend to reach because the 50pc Wiha terminator set I bought months ago has yet to have a single bit fail on me. I generally pass on the Milwaukees to get rid of them, Makitas if I like the person asking, and with the better fit I use the DeWalt maxfits in hand drivers, replacing them as I lose them. For real though, Wiha terminators are the best I’ve ever used, hands down.

    Reply
  23. Dan

    Oct 3, 2019

    Milwaukee is supposed to be coming out with one that is guaranteed not to fail
    Forget the name , I would like to try it out

    Reply
    • Lance

      Oct 5, 2019

      That’s a good one!

      Reply
    • Brian M

      Oct 7, 2019

      They already came out, kept breaking and they discontinued them less than one month after release.

      I’m a Milwaukee power tool guy but their bits are absolutely garbage.

      Reply
  24. Dave

    Oct 3, 2019

    I PREFER HERCULES FROM HARBOR FREIGHT … LAST JUST AS LONG AT A FRACTION OF THE PRICE

    Reply
  25. Todd

    Oct 3, 2019

    hitachi are the best

    Reply
    • Corey Moore

      Oct 4, 2019

      This is the first I’ve heard this. I actually didn’t even know Hitachi made impact bits. Can’t seem to find any comparisons online, can you elaborate?

      Reply
      • Kilroy

        Oct 4, 2019

        I’m not sure who “really” makes them, and I don’t go through enough screw bits enough to have an informed opinion, but Menards stores in the Midwest generally carry a decent selection of Hitachi bits if you’d like to try them.

        Reply
  26. Toolfreak

    Oct 3, 2019

    I’d check the clearance tools and get whatever bits or sets are super cheap there.

    If there weren’t any there or in the tool area, I’d head to Lowe’s and buy Bosch.

    Reply
  27. Jason McWilliams

    Oct 3, 2019

    Milwaukee all day everyday best tools on the market hands down. I will also use Makita I love their double sided bits with different sizes and their super strong magnet. As far as Dewalt there bits are pure garbage they wear out really fast and are not constructed well. If I need a cheap bit holder I will buy Ryobi.

    Reply
    • Chris

      Oct 4, 2019

      How much did Milwaukee pay you to say that lol

      Reply
  28. James

    Oct 3, 2019

    In terms of quality, I prefer Bosch and Makita, but do use a lot of Dewalt too since they are frequently on sale. I haven’t had very good luck with Milwaukee bits.

    I actually like to get different brands for different bits or sizes to make it easier to distinguish them when switching back and forth.

    Reply
  29. Marco

    Oct 3, 2019

    Tried them all. Makita gold bits, 25 pack if available. Can’t beat them for everyday use

    Reply
  30. Rb

    Oct 3, 2019

    Which ever one will stay in my spare bit holder on my drill I use both Milwaukee and dewalt. Milwaukee seems to have a harder bit but will break I like it to use on harden screws like drywall screws. Dewalt seems to have more meat on the Phillips tip.
    But will wear out quicker on drywall screws. The only Makita bit I use was double headed didn’t fit in my impact well. And they look kind of cheap I don’t see them around much

    Reply
  31. Mike

    Oct 4, 2019

    I use the Milwaukee bits as I love their combos that go on sale. But I really do love my Dewalt #2 Phillips & Robby MaxFits (6″). I’ve never had a problem with them driving wood or steel screws and never had them slip/break.

    Reply
  32. Ian M

    Oct 4, 2019

    Bosch, they seem to be the hardest wearing. I am a huge fan of Milwaukee but their bits just don’t cut it, they wear out way to easily

    Reply
  33. Skye A Cohen

    Oct 4, 2019

    It’s a well known thing in my world, residential remodeling in Portland OR, not all but most of us at least I’m my corner of the world here very much dislike milwuakee driver bits and feel their hole saws are average, sawsall blades good for metal garbage for wood, rotohammer bits below average.. good tools but bits and blades meh. We all still end up with them because if their availability and decent prices.

    I think Makita and DeWalt both have decent driver bits, usually if Bosch makes whatever bbit or blade I’ll buy that first, Freud Diablo too.

    Reply
  34. Tom

    Oct 4, 2019

    I am a huge dewalt fan. But I’ve recently been using wera bits. They are great!

    Reply
  35. Jo B

    Oct 4, 2019

    As an Electrician I use 6″ Robertson #2 bits mostly. From experience, the DeWalt are very soft and before fast. They also wreck the screws on the electric panels, especially GE panels. The Milwaukee are equally as poor and soft. Couldn’t find Makita to try. What lasts the best by far, and I mean by far are those that come from Rack-A-Teer. They have a soft body and and hardened tip and are designed for electrical use. They last roughly 6x long than Lenox, DeWalt, and Milwaukee so far. I’ve also used their blue #2 Philips and it’s my preference.

    Reply
    • Steven

      Oct 4, 2019

      Yes, rack a tiers make, what i think the best bits. Not the prettiest but they just seem to last longer and hold even low grade screws better than___brands
      But given from this massive spread of brand preference, get whatever.
      Tool performance and speed puts alot of demand on drill bits. Depending on what your base material and angles of installation or extraction, bits die, there is no Highlander of bits, they all die regardless of advertised claims.

      Reply
  36. Big Adam

    Oct 4, 2019

    Who ever buys 2 or 5 packs?
    I’m nothing like a power user but I’d not look at anything smaller than a 25x pack.

    Reply
  37. jeff

    Oct 4, 2019

    I have some no name brand ones that I love, no idea where I got them. I also have some Milwaukee Philips bits, they cam out to easily compared to the unknown bits. Ive actually just debated throwing the remaining Milwaukee bits out.

    Love my m18 tools though!

    Reply
  38. Matt J

    Oct 4, 2019

    I prefer Makita, but HD has a terrible selection of individual bits and I need another multi-bit set like a hole in the head. I’ll usually pick up Milwaukee if I’m at HD, Bosch if at Lowe’s. If it’s not emergent, I will order Makita online.

    Reply
  39. MrWeedley

    Oct 4, 2019

    I just use the free ones that come with the big boxes of drywall screws, I’ve accumulated more than I I have to replace…

    Reply
  40. Flotsam

    Oct 4, 2019

    Tried them all. Makita gold just seem to fit perfectly!

    Reply
  41. SP

    Oct 4, 2019

    SIGNET (I think its originaly a Canadian brand and produce mostly hand tools and accessories) is widely available in Asia and the mid east. I never heared or saw that brand name mentioned in the USA. Does anyone know that brand? I would compare their tools and equipment to Snap On.
    I think (not sure) Wera is marketed in my area under different name.
    Irwin, DeWalt and Metabo olso durable and affordable where i live.

    Reply
  42. Steve Goodman

    Oct 4, 2019

    Have used all brands over the years. Lately it’s been Dewalt bit holders which are awesome. For long (non-holder bits) it’s whatever is around thought the dual end bosch bits are pretty good. What I’ve really noticed over the last few years is that Philips head is only used if it comes with a finish item or doors etc. pretty much use T25 for all non framing gun activities and tacking.

    Reply
  43. Cr8on

    Oct 4, 2019

    None of the above, closest HD is 20 miles away. I buy Bosch bits almost exclusively now and Menards carries almost every size.

    Reply
  44. Romeo

    Oct 4, 2019

    I have used dewalt bits but they always break even though the ones with the same impact are broken, the makita only twist then I guess maybe the new ones from Milwaukee are a little better

    Reply
  45. Adz

    Oct 4, 2019

    Have used all over the years and have found Milwaukee shockwave to be best ones, one bit has driven thousands of wafer screws into 2mm 3mm RHS using dewalt impact drivers other bits twist break tips also Quality of fasteners is a factor

    Reply
  46. Thom

    Oct 4, 2019

    Milwaukee, Makita then Dewalt. I burn out the Dewalt bits pretty easily and tend to avoid them if I can. Maybe its because I usually buy then in holiday promo sets at Home Depot. Are the blister carded bits better quality?

    Reply
  47. Chris

    Oct 4, 2019

    I use DeWalt and Bosch… Father in law got some Milwaukee bits Last year for Christmas… Well their in the trash now, pure junk. I told him they won’t last and been in the landfill for about 6 months now

    Reply
  48. Nathan

    Oct 4, 2019

    Germain to the directed question at hand of those I would buy either the Dewalt or the milwaukee bits probably in order of cheapest or number offered for the money. Example last time I bought any philips bits I bought 12 or 15 dewalt max fit 2 inch philips #2’s that have that nifty mag collar. They work great in the impact driver and I think I still have 7 left. Also it was on sale at the time and cost per bit was right.

    Now outside of the directed question – I rarely go to Home Depot but I do cross shop there. I find I get better stuff from Lowes – either plumbing stuffs, hardware stuffs, wood, etc. and the prices are often similar and they are less than 2 miles apart so it’s a roll of the dice for me. To that end – going to lowes I’m just as likely to buy Bosch stuffs for bits or other brands.

    Reply
  49. Daniel

    Oct 4, 2019

    Milwaukee.

    Reply
  50. Jeremy Hicks

    Oct 4, 2019

    Depends on what you are using the bits for. Some are made for drill/drivers and some are made for impacts. The bit you choose depends on how you are going to use it. As someone who works at one of the big box stores I have had the opportunity to learn the differences and which last the longest. From what my contractors and repeat customers tell me is that Milwaukee is by far the best and DeWalt is a distant third. So again it all depends on it’s use

    Reply
    • Corey Moore

      Oct 5, 2019

      Outside of quality control issues that I believe account for most of this vast diversity in experience- operator error most definitely accounts for the rest. I wouldn’t write off purchasing trends as relevant data, but likewise I wouldn’t stake the real world truth of what’s actually best in the field, off of just what the box store patrons are reporting.

      Reply
  51. Adam

    Oct 4, 2019

    Wiha because you can buy them in bulk packs of 250 bits at a time and they’re in the same general performance envelope as the other major independent brands. At less than $1.25 per bit, they’re unquestionably an economical option. For the average home person, it’s obviously overkill to purchase 250 bits at a time, but if you’re a professional or power user in some area, that’s the best deal you can find for decent quality bits.

    Building decks & fences, it’s easy to go through a couple dozen bits a day (not counting dropped and lost bits) because you’re driving thousands of screws and they simply wear out. When driving that many screws, you want speed and efficiency – the minute a bit starts to wear out, you swap for a fresh one. The cost of a fresh bit is negligible compared to the value of lost time fighting a worn bit.

    Most decent brands will do around 300 screws into treated pine, give or take some, before they start to cam-out or simply break.

    Reply
  52. Kizzle

    Oct 4, 2019

    Bosch for sure.

    Reply
  53. Diamond Dave

    Oct 4, 2019

    I’ve am a handyman and DIY’er so I don’t go through a ton of bit drivers like some who drive hundreds of screws daily. With that being said I have an accumulation of bit tips with the majority being Dewalt. As one poster put it, I have bought so many on sale promo kits in the past that I think I am set for life however I still continually look at the Dewalt Lineup on the wall at Depot because of new stuff that comes out and I may not of heard of it.

    Reply
  54. Renato

    Oct 4, 2019

    Makita.

    Reply
  55. PETE

    Oct 4, 2019

    For phillips- Makita Golds for sure.
    For all other sizes- milwaukee.

    I’ve said it before and i’ll say it again. DeWalt bits are the WORST.

    Reply
  56. S

    Oct 4, 2019

    I forgot about Bosch – those are great, as well.

    S

    Reply
  57. Koko The Talking Ape

    Oct 4, 2019

    It’s a little strange that these opinions are so varied. I imagine part of what is going on is that people aren’t distinguishing between impact-rated and regular bits, and whether they are using them with impact drivers or drill/drivers. A hard but brittle bit might last longer in a drill/driver but might break in an impact driver.

    I wonder what it would take to do some sort of objective comparison of these bits. It could start with just measuring surface hardness, depth of hardening, elastic coefficient, etc. (plus a plain-language interpretation of the results.) Those aren’t simple topics, but at least it would provide a means to compare.

    Or somebody could do some kind of “real-life” comparison. It could just be doing their day job, but just being systematic about using only a specific brand for a day or a week, and paying attention to how many bits they go through, and whether they break or wear out. Fine Homebuilding sometimes has articles like that.

    Reply
  58. DENNIS

    Oct 4, 2019

    I lean towards milwalkee followed
    By Dewalt then Mikeeta. The quality
    To me stands for its self. Home depot’s my go to place, Lowes has
    Been bought out by Stanley Decker,and there customer service
    Has hit rock bottom, so, I’m willing
    To live with Home Depots selection ps I’ve been asked 4 times may I help
    You, just saying.

    Reply
  59. BlueCrafted

    Oct 4, 2019

    My go-to bits are bosch’s impact tough bits. They’ve been great so far. But between those listed, I’d go for the makita golds. I have a bunch of those too and they work just as good.

    Reply
  60. Jarred

    Oct 4, 2019

    I’m in the what’s on sale group, really if it’s a good set I’ll buy it if it’s on sale! I’ve bought Irwin buts for super cheap on clearance for $2-3 and they work great, Bosch bits also for super cheap, no problems, I just never really buy ryobi or similar

    Reply
  61. Chris

    Oct 4, 2019

    I have used them all and the Milwaukee hold up the best. You have to hit a specialty store or online for some of the longer sizes, but I have yet to strip one.

    Reply
  62. David

    Oct 4, 2019

    Has anyone tried Masterforce or Montana brands at Menards?

    Reply
  63. Lynyrd

    Oct 4, 2019

    Bosch. For electrical work, the Bosch 2 in 1 P2/Sq2 is the best.

    Reply
  64. Don

    Oct 4, 2019

    Bosch all the way.

    Reply
  65. Ray

    Oct 4, 2019

    Like many of the posts I also have had problems with the Milwaukee bits. They seem like their quality has dropped. I prefer the Bosch or Makita bits. Masterforce is a
    Menard house brand and only good thing about that is the lifetime guarantee.

    Reply
  66. Greg

    Oct 4, 2019

    Vermont’s were great when they were the 2R’s . That reduced head allowed the bit to seat much better so you didn’t wear them out very quick.
    Grabbers are great they are just like the 2R. Don’t have the slip off when starting.

    Reply
  67. Joe

    Oct 4, 2019

    I use Milwaukee everything! I have just about every tool Milwaukee makes except the small m12 stuff. The new Milwaukee bits with the wear guard tip that is silver in color seem to do exactly what they say they won’t. I bought the 3 inch t-25, t-20, square #2, Phillips #2 and I’m not impressed at all! They wear down soooooo fast. I have used there previous line (all black) and gotten months out of one bit….this new line…I’m lucky if I make it through the day before I toss it. I would go with the Makita out of the three you have to choose from.

    Reply
  68. Amy

    Oct 5, 2019

    Snap-on ACR (Anti Cam-out Removal) bits.

    Reply
  69. Bonson

    Oct 6, 2019

    Of the 3 in the original post, I’ve used Milwaukee and Dewalt’s… Not in love with either but have had annoyances with the DeWalt maxfits (Philips and Robertson in my experience… Haven’t used others). They require a more perfect alignment than any other bit. Which is an unnecessary distraction that takes away focus and increases frustration.

    If I were to get one set next in an emergency, i’d get the Makitas for no other reason than to try them.

    Reply
  70. Shawn Brubacher

    Oct 7, 2019

    I’ve come to the conclusion that impact bits are disposable. We’ve tried several different brands including the ones mentioned and they all break or strip out eventually, no matter if you use Phillips, square or t bits. We have pro grade impacts so that probably makes a difference too. Our older impacts don’t ruin bits as fast but also have way less power.

    Reply
    • Steve Goodman

      Oct 8, 2019

      Totally agree. Cost of bits is negligible

      Reply
  71. Ken

    Oct 7, 2019

    Bulk bits from local trade-oriented hardware stores (Preston hardware or Ottawa Fastener Supply), otherwise whatever quality brand is on sale…

    Reply
  72. Andreas

    Oct 8, 2019

    Personally i go for the bosch bits, they are cheaper and seem to last longer for myself. After that i usually get whatever is better priced which is generally mastercraft. I used to use the dewalt bits, however i found they started making them alot cheaper and they break far too often.

    Reply
  73. Chris

    Oct 8, 2019

    At least for Robertsons, both DeWalt and Milwaulkee are garbage, paulin are the best that home depot has/used to have (I haven’t seen them lately, but they are/were usually hidden near the contractor stuff and away from the tool aisle so I may have just missed them). This is Home Depot Canada so your mileage my vary.

    https://www.hpaulin.com/media/wysiwyg/pdf/Pro-Tip.pdf

    Reply
  74. Edward Frattarelli

    Oct 10, 2019

    Milwaukee, everytime! I’ve tried every kind of dewalt and they wear out quickly. Ive tried Makita a couple of times but the Milwaukee seem to last much longer.

    Reply
  75. Jeremiah Leonard

    Mar 21, 2020

    I have a Makita drill-&-impact set, but Milwaukee bits seem to work really well.

    Reply
  76. DRT

    Apr 25, 2020

    Project Farm did a very comprehensive and scientific test of Phillips #2 impact driver bits. Search Youtube and it should come right up. Results summarized in charts, close up photos and video of bits failing. Well worth the time to watch.

    Reply
    • Shaky

      Apr 25, 2020

      The Wiha and Milwaukee both did pretty well in the Project Farm video. Wiha is pricey, and you need to order them ahead of time. They do work well.

      One other thing to look at, check out the Wera brand bit holders. They have a typical insert , (889/4/1), and one that has a sliding magnet (887/4/1). I recently bought both. They are much better than all the previous ones from every other brand that I have used. I don’t like wasting money on the straight bits, that are just as long as a magnetic insert version.

      I mostly use them with Milwaukee bits, because they were on special over the Xmas holiday, and I have a bunch of them. I also have Makita, Wiha, DeWalt, some off-brand, and some old Stanley branded ones. I stick to the Milwaukee and Wiha bits.

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Todd Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Newsletter

Sign up to receive the latest tool news.

Recent Comments

  • Nate on New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All: “Where is the cyclone physically located? I’ve built a lot of ’em over the years and I don’t see space…”
  • neandrewthal on New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All: “I have the old backpack vac and I never use it. Basically useless with dust. The Fuel packout vac is…”
  • TomD on New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All: “The most annoying thing about the old one (which I have) is that even slightly pulling on the hose (buy…”
  • Itcd on New at Lowe’s: Rainbow Kobalt Hex Keys: “Those end up sliding off.”
  • Stuart on New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All: “I wouldn’t bother with a 1.5Ah battery, but the 5Ah should be usable if that’s all you have. Most brands…”
  • Stuart on New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All: “I’m not familiar with that Makita model. It would be interesting to compare the two, but I think they have…”

Recent Posts

  • New Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Backpack Vacuum Brings it All
  • Home Depot Follows July 4th with New Tool Deals (7/5/25)
  • New at Lowe's: Rainbow Kobalt Hex Keys
  • Patent Dispute Over Dewalt Construction Jack has been Settled
  • Dewalt Launched a New 20V Atomic Cordless Hammer Drill Kit
  • Let's Talk About Amazon's USB-Charged Cordless Mini Chainsaw
  • These Mini Stackable Organizer Tool Boxes Look Better than Dewalt's
  • Amazon has a Name Brand Bit Ratchet Set for Surprisingly Cheap
ToolGuyd New Tool Reviews Image

New Tool Reviews

Buying Guides

  • Best Cordless Drills
  • Best Euro Hand Tool Brands
  • Best Tool Brands
  • Best Cordless Power Tool Brands
  • Tools for New Parents
  • Ultimate Tool Gift & Upgrade Guide
ToolGuyd Knife Reviews Image

Knife Reviews

ToolGuyd Multi-Tool Reviews Image

Multi-Tool Reviews

ToolGuyd LED Flashlight and Worklight Reviews Image

LED Light Reviews

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Stores
  • Videos
  • AMZN Deal Finder
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Disclosure